UTILITY E-ALERT
#1454– January 24, 2020
Table of Contents
CLIMATE CHANGE
COAL – U.S.
Wyoming and Montana challenge denial of Millennium Bulk Coal Terminal Permit in Supreme Court
Dairyland Power Cooperative to retire Genoa Station #3 in 2021
Two
Large Coal-fired Power Plant retirements in 2020 in Kentucky
COAL – WORLD
·
Global activists urge Bangladesh PM
to scrap Plans for Coal-fired Power Plants
·
Indian Power Utility lobbies to weaken Pollution
Standard
·
German Government negotiates Coal exit
but waters down Commission Recommendations
·
Modernization of the 680 MW Lignite-Fired
Power Station Kosovo B
BIOMASS
GAS TURBINES
WASTE-TO-ENERGY
NUCLEAR
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
CLIMATE CHANGE
The Opportunistic Antidote to the Climate Change
Doomsday Scenario
The U.S. Administration will support a trillion-tree planting campaign along
with many other nations. However, the U.S. still believes that warming may be
caused by solar activity and that increased CO2 levels are a result
and not cause of the warming. What if the U.S. government officials are wrong
and the doomsday predicters are right?
They say we are reaching a tipping point and it will be difficult if not
impossible to prevent the catastrophic floods and fires without immediate
cessation of fossil fuel burning.
Fossil fuel elimination will certainly threaten economic prosperity throughout
Asia. If Asian nations are not
participants any reductions in Europe and the U.S. will be insignificant.
The solution to this dilemma is a Doomsday antidote which is Opportunistic
Biomass Combustion and Sequestration. A UK consortium is already generating
a significant amount of its electricity from biomass burning and will be
distributing CO2 and hydrogen to industrial facilities and
sequestering the remaining CO2 underground.
In Canada the SaskPower Boundary Dam 3 coal fired plant has now supplied
3 million tons of CO2 for enhanced oil recovery.
So, there is no doubt that biomass combustion and CO2 sequestration
is a legitimate option. The
question is how costly will it be?
It will not be cheap but on the other hand if the doomsday believers are correct
then it could be the only option. This biomass combustion/sequestration will
“suck the CO2 out of the air.” Wind and solar are just neutral. So,
the biomass option is the antidote for the doomsday scenario.
The greater the impending doom the greater the amount of biomass which should be
grown, combusted and sequestered. But to be opportunistic why spend the money if
it is not needed. So, the opportunistic approach is to build and retain biomass
capable fossil fuel boilers. Should the coal fired boilers being retired in the
U.S. be scrapped or should they be mothballed and ready for conversion to
biomass firing if needed?
Should utilities reconsider scrapping the coal plants and building natural
gas-fired units? Or should they
design natural gas fired plants for eventual biomass gasification and
sequestration?
Should the Philippines make its new fleet of coal fired boilers biomass ready?
It is a major target of the trillion-tree initiative. There needs to be an
optimization of four initiatives.
·
Tree planting for long term sequestration (hundred years)
·
Biomass fuel growth with the most mass in the shortest amount of time
·
Biomass combustion
·
CO2 use and sequestration
Due to the uncertainties, the wise course is to spend modest amounts to make
combustion plants ready for biomass combustion while continuing to develop new
sequestration strategies including substituting CO2 for water in
hydraulic fracturing.
A biomass capable electricity generator becomes the highest-ranking choice with
wind, solar, hydro and other options falling behind. Biomass may never be burned
but if the doomsday scenario becomes part of the strategy then it is the
antidote.
Details on the strategies, projects, and on all coal-fired generators around the
world are included Utility Tracking
System.
http://home.mcilvainecompany.com/index.php/databases/42ei-utility-tracking-system
UK Coalition will sequester CO2
from Biomass Combustion
A coalition of industry, power and oil and gas firms in the U.K. are
collaborating on a net-zero industrial cluster that they believe will establish
a template for any country seeking a carbon-neutral economy. This was reported
by John Parnell in Greentech Media.
The coalition includes
Drax.
The company used to be best known for running the Drax Power Station, a
4-gigawatt coal-fired power plant in the north of England. Today 2.6 gigawatts
have been converted to biomass. The Drax Group has a spinoff in the U.S.
producing wood pellets, pumped hydro and a pipeline of gas power-plant
developments.
This mixed-fuel power complex on England’s east coast is at the heart of an
early proposal to send the U.K. on its way toward a net-zero economy. Its
biomass generators will be connected to carbon capture, utilization and storage
(CCUS) technology.
Meanwhile, National Grid, which runs the U.K. power transmission network and gas
distribution grid, will create a regional CO2 network offering industry and
petrochemical complexes down the Humber River the chance to feed into the pipe.
At that point, Norwegian oil and gas major Equinor gets involved, providing a
long-term home for that CO2 in the North Sea.
In tandem, the negative-emissions electricity at Drax will create hydrogen that
will be distributed down the Humber industrial cluster via a new network to be
developed by National Grid.
The timelines for the project, particularly the CCUS
component, could be shorter than expected. The companies involved include Drax,
Shell, and the utility SSE, NGV has developed the Endurance store — a saline
aquifer located 90 kilometers off the east coast of England in the Bunter
sandstone formation in the southern North Sea. It is ideally situated to
facilitate CCUS developments in the Humber region and could potentially be used
by other cluster developments, such as Teesside in the northeast of the U.K. or
Rotterdam in the Netherlands.”
SaskPower
Boundary Dam has now sequestered 3 Million Tons of CO2
The carbon capture and storage (CCS) facility at
SaskPower’s Boundary Dam (BD) Power Station had another good year in
2019, according to data released by SaskPower.
The facility prevented more than 616,000 tons of
carbon dioxide (CO2) from entering the earth’s atmosphere, even
though there was a scheduled shutdown that lasted about two months.
There was also scheduled maintenance in the second
half of November and the first week of December that took the facility offline.
It was also a year of milestones and firsts for CCS.
The CCS facility eclipsed the three-million-ton mark
for CO2 captured and sequestered on November 4. It took a little more
than five years to hit that mark.
The CCS facility also hasn’t had a lost-time accident
since it came online in October 2014.
“You see the size and the scope and the equipment and
the chemicals that we’re handling and all those sorts of things, and 24 hour a
day operation, 365 days a year, that plant has equipment running in,” said
Howard Matthews, the vice-president of power production at SaskPower.
The 20,000 HP Compressor inside the CCS facility also
went through its first overhaul and inspection last spring. “It was due for its
regularly scheduled five-year dismantle and inspection, and a 57-day outage to
allow us to take that compressor (apart),” said Matthews.
There have been some challenges. The boiler in Unit 3
has encountered tube leaks, because Matthews said the fuel the boilers burn
wears the tubes out. “After five years of hard run time on the BD 3 boiler,
we’ve seen a couple of tube leaks. Of course, when the boiler’s not operating,
there’s no flue gas and no steam for the CCS facility and it takes CCS offline,”
said Matthews.
There will be some scheduled maintenance at Boundary
Dam this year. They won’t be to the same degree as the two-month shutdown of a
year ago, but there will be regularly scheduled maintenance for cleaning work in
the tower, absorber and heat exchangers.
Nothing unusual is slated, which means there should
be very good performance in 2020, Matthews said.
“It does take a bit of time when you come offline,”
said Matthews. “Things cool down and you have to get the chemical back into spec
and the temperatures back correct, and then go back online with the
compressors.”
He believes there has been some really good progress
on the facility over the past five years. SaskPower’s game plan when it embarked
on the CCS facility was, first and foremost, to prove the technology and to show
it would work as intended. Matthews believes they have done that.
They also wanted to improve reliability.
“We’ve seen substantial improvement in reliability
with some of the work that we’ve done in the past couple of years,” said
Matthews.
Now their focus is surrounding cost reduction and
trying to get their costs for CCS as low as possible.
“The whole point of this is with reliability and cost
improvements, to give the best information that we can to the decision-makers
going forward. Those decisions won’t be made for some time. We continue to work
on reliability and reducing our costs,” said Matthews.
Trump backs Trillion Tree Initiative
President Trump, on
January 21, announced the United States will join the One Trillion Trees
Initiative. Trump made the announcement during an address to global business
leaders gathered for the annual event in Davos, Switzerland. "We're committed to
conserving the majesty of God’s creation and the natural beauty of our world,"
Trump said, adding that the U.S. "will continue to show strong leadership in
restoring, growing and better managing our trees and our forests.”
At the 4,000-megawatt Drax plant in the UK, biomass
is being burned as a replacement for coal.
Furthermore, the utility is funding a sequestration program with the goal
of permanently encapsulating CO2 underground.
When you combine the Trillion Tree Initiative and
biomass combustion and sequestration you have a program to actually reduce CO2
not just avoid emitting more. This means that there is no tipping point beyond
which there is no potential for carbon reduction. It is a good bet that our
views on climate change will be considerably different 20 years from now than
they are now.
If it turns out that the impacts of elevated CO2
levels are even worse than now anticipated the combination of planting, biomass
combustion, and sequestration is even more important. If it turns out as it did
in the case of dioxins where the harm was vastly over-estimated or ulcers where
the true cause turned out to be a virus then there is a flexible program, which
will respond appropriately. Here are the impacts on CO2 levels of the
various technologies.
Technology |
Impact on CO2 levels |
Wind and solar |
zero |
Coal combustion |
increase |
Additional tree planting |
decrease |
Equilibrium where a number of new trees
are offset by decaying trees |
zero |
Biomass combustion |
zero |
Biomass combustion and sequestration |
decrease |
So, the flexible program incorporates additional
tree planting until equilibrium is reached. Then dying trees are substituted for
fossil fuels. If more reduction is needed sequestration of the biomass combustor
emissions is undertaken.
In 2006, the Billion Tree Campaign was launched, by
the (UNEP) as a response to the challenges of global
warming,
The Billion Tree Campaign was handed over to the
Plant-for-the-Planet Foundation in December 2011, an organization that has been
participating in the Billion Tree Campaign since 2007. In December 2017,
following the discovery that there are more than three trillion trees on Earth,
the planting target was revised to a trillion trees and the Billion Tree
Campaign became the Trillion Tree Campaign.
One estimate found that this number of trees would
cancel out the last 10 years of CO2 emissions and sequester 160
billion tons of carbon. However, the
intergovernmental panel on climate change is even more positive. They estimate
that one trillion trees will store an
estimated 205 billion tons of carbon, or about two-thirds of the carbon that
humans have added to the atmosphere since the 1800s.
The problem with this approach is that 30 years from now in 2050 there will be
lots of trees dying and emitting CO2. However, at that time the
biomass can be harvested and burned in power generators. If the 500,000 MW of
new coal-fired capacity, which is built is designed to be biomass ready, it can
be converted making each of the generators carbon neutral. If this CO2 is
then sequestered, these generators would be as the UK describes it “sucking the
CO2 out of the air. They would be the only generator type which
actually reduces CO2.
What are the costs? The continuation of the coal-fired power program would net
a savings of $7.2 trillion over 30 years. This saving would primarily be in a
few Asian countries. The tree planting program would cost $700
billion resulting in a $6.5 trillion saving over the 30 years. For the period
2050-2080 the coal-fired power plants would be converted to burn biomass and if
necessary, also sequester CO2.
Sequestration would raise costs of electricity generation and make this approach
relatively more costly but only after 2050. Since biomass combustion and
sequestration is the only CO2 reduction option it can be employed if
necessary.
Activity |
2020-2050 |
2050-80 |
Tree Planting |
-$700 billion |
-$700 billion |
Saving with coal vs. more expensive generation options |
$7.2 trillion |
|
Net savings |
$6.5 trillion |
|
Biomass combustion with or without sequestration. |
Biomass combustion without sequestration would increasingly be
implemented. |
Sequestration would be an
alternative to other renewables and actually remove CO2 and
not just be neutral. |
In 2050 these biomass- ready coal-fired power plants would have already served
their purpose as coal generators. Their conversion to biomass would ensure that
the forestation approach is sustaining in terms of CO2 minimization.
However, if there are major improvements in the cost of wind and solar and no
need to reduce CO2 the
plants could be retired. But since they would be the only alternative for
dealing with dying trees, they will continue to be utilized.
Another option is to convert these plants to biomass combustion at an earlier date. There is optimism that the cost of sequestration can be greatly reduced through programs underway at Drax and other locations. If some of the most pessimistic forecasters are right and climate change becomes a crisis, then the biomass generation and sequestration becomes the only route to solve the problem since it reduces CO2.
The present CO2 level is 410 ppm. But a massive tree planting program
could have the effect of reducing CO2 by more than 1 ppm per year.
The net effect would be a 390 ppm CO2 level in 2050.
Initiative |
2020-2050
ppm CO2 |
2050-2080
ppm CO2 |
Existing |
410 |
390 |
New Coal and Other |
30 |
20 |
Tree Planting |
-50 |
0 |
Biomass Combustion at most former coal plants
and Sequestration |
0 |
-30 |
CO2 level in the atmosphere at end of period |
390 |
380 |
After 2050 solar and wind will be more cost effective particularly if energy
storage methods advance. The need for new coal-fired power plants will cease but
there will be other sources with the potential to add 20 ppm to the atmosphere
in the 2050-2080 timeframe.
In 2050 there will be a very large quantity of fuel contained in elderly trees.
They can be harvested and burned as fuel. The biomass would replace coal in
existing boilers. They would not
emit CO2 to the atmosphere if there is sequestration. New trees that
replace the old trees will continue to remove CO2. So, this
initiative would more than offset man-made sources and the CO2 level
could drop to 380 ppm in 2080.
CO2 sequestration has been commercially
practiced for decades. One use has been enhanced oil recovery. CO2 is
being piped long distances in many areas. Presently it is economic only if it
has a use such as recovering oil. The UK believes that new carbon capture
technologies will drive down the cost over the coming years. But whether it is
inexpensive or expensive, the situation is manageable in 2050 due to the ability
to suck out the CO2. This control provides flexibility. It will allow
construction of coal-fired power plants in India, the Philippines, Indonesia,
Bangladesh, and Vietnam and still achieve climate change goals.
NETL Project
Validates Geologic Storage of CO2 to boost Energy Production,
reduce Carbon Footprint
The carbon footprint created by industry and other
human activity in Big Sky Country — the area stretching across the Great Plains
and into Canada — can be reduced using technology pioneered by NETL
and partners at a leading research university.
Work completed as part
of the NETL-backed Plains CO2
Reduction (PCOR) Partnership demonstrates not only the ability to reduce carbon
dioxide emissions, it also enhances the efficiency of oil production, an
important consideration to bolster domestic energy production.
PCOR is one of the U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE) seven
Regional Carbon Sequestration Partnerships (RCSPs), which have been laying the
groundwork since 2003 for large-scale geologic storage of CO2
in the United States as a means of mitigating effects of climate change while
still allowing for the efficient and affordable use of fossil fuels for energy
production.
RCSP activities, supported by NETL, have included assessments of geologic and
terrestrial storage potential in each region, followed by small-scale validation
tests and six large-scale (greater than 1 million metric tons) geologic storage
field experiments.
The Energy and Environmental Research Center (EERC) at the
University of North Dakota leads the PCOR Partnership. Throughout its
history, PCOR has engaged a membership of more than 120 partner organizations
drawn from industry, government and research institutions to foster carbon
capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS) deployment across a vast region.
The positive environmental impact of PCOR is significant. Stretching from
Missouri through the northern Great Plains to northcentral Canada, this region
possesses outstanding potential for widespread CCUS deployment because it has
significant geologic storage resources and an extensive fossil fuel-based
industry. Furthermore, several active CCUS projects in the region are already
setting an example for future work by demonstrating safe and effective carbon
management strategies with attendant economic benefits.
Another key achievement of the PCOR Partnership was its assessment and
monitoring of more than 6 million metric tons of CO2
storage associated with the enhanced oil recovery (EOR) operations, which inject
captured CO2 into oil
reservoirs to increase production, at Denbury Resources’ Bell Creek oilfield in
southeast Montana.
NETL-supported
Petra Nova Project celebrates Three Years of Sustainable Operation
The
world’s largest operating post-combustion carbon dioxide (CO2)
capture system Petra Nova celebrates its third anniversary January 10, 2020. The
project, supported by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office
of Fossil Energy and administered by NETL, is demonstrating how
carbon capture, utilization, and storage technologies can economically support
the flexibility and sustainability of fossil fuels at commercial scale.
Owned and operated by NRG Energy Inc. and JX Nippon Oil and
Gas Exploration Corporation, Petra Nova is located southwest of Houston
Texas and applies carbon capture technology to an existing unit at the
coal-fired W.A. Parish Generating Station.
Commencing operation in 2017,
the Petra Nova project addresses capture and
beneficial reuse of CO2
from coal-based electricity production. The project uses an advanced amine-based
process to capture CO2,
which is then compressed, dried, and transported for enhanced oil recovery (EOR)
at the West Ranch Oil Field in Jackson County, Texas, to boost oil production.
Using the Kansai Mitsubishi Carbon Dioxide Recovery (KM-CDR) Process©, the Petra
Nova project is designed to capture approximately 90% of the CO2
from a 240-megawatt equivalent flue gas slipstream — which is approximately 1.6
million tons of CO2
per year (assuming an 85% availability). Since beginning operations in January
2017, Petra Nova has captured more than 3.9 million short (U.S.) tons of CO2
and West Ranch Oil Field has produced more than 4.2 million barrels of oil
through EOR.
COAL – U.S.
EPA approves Utah’s Regional
Haze Plan
EPA
is proposing to take action pursuant to section 110 of the Clean Air Act (CAA or
Act) on State Implementation Plan (SIP) revisions submitted by the State of Utah
on July 3, 2019, as supplemented on December 3, 2019, to satisfy certain
regional haze requirements for the program’s first implementation period. The
EPA is proposing to approve the July 2019 SIP revision that provides an
alternative to best available retrofit technology (BART) controls for nitrogen
oxides (NOx) at the PacifiCorp Hunter and Huntington
power plants. The EPA proposes to find that the Utah NOx BART Alternative for
Hunter and Huntington would provide greater reasonable progress toward natural
visibility conditions than BART, in accordance with the requirements of the CAA
and the EPA’s Regional Haze Rule (RHR). In conjunction with this proposed
approval, EPA proposes to withdraw the federal implementation plan (FIP) that
addresses NOx BART for the Hunter and Huntington power plants. The EPA also
proposes to approve the December 3, 2019 SIP supplement that would require
reporting of all deviations from compliance with the applicable requirements
under BART and the BART Alternative, including the emission limits for Hunter
and Huntington.
Federal Register/Vol. 85, No. 14/Wednesday, January 22, 2020 / Proposed Rules
California’s Richmond City Council has approved an ordinance to phase out
storage of coal and petroleum coke in that city. The ordinance gives
Levin-Richmond Terminal Corporation on the Santa Fe Channel east of Point
Richmond and south of the Iron Triangle neighborhood three years to wind down
coal and coke storage operations. The terminal stores coal shipped from Utah
mines before export to Japan. Richmond City Mayor Mr. Tom Butt said “The coal
ordinance is created following complaints from the public about increased coal
dust in the air in parts of Richmond. It would govern only the storage of coal
in Richmond; it will not have any effect on transportation of coal through the
city by rail.”
Levin-Richmond Terminal is a dry bulk cargo marine terminal on the San Francisco
Bay in Richmond, California. It is privately owned by the Levin Richmond
Terminal Corporation. Levin Richmond Terminal Corporation began exporting coal
in 2013. It had already been exporting petcoke for decades. The petcoke comes
from the Phillips66 refinery to load onto boats headed for Australia and Europe.
Wyoming and Montana challenge denial of
Millennium Bulk Coal Terminal Permit in Supreme Court
Wyoming Governor Mark Gordon announced that Wyoming and Montana have jointly
asked the United States Supreme Court to hear a challenge to Washington State’s
denial of the proposed Millennium Bulk coal terminal in Longview in Washington.
Governor Gordon said that specifically, the two states seek to invoke the US
Supreme Court's original jurisdiction, which allows for disputes between states
to bypass lower courts and proceed directly to the US Supreme Court. Wyoming and
Montana argue that Washington's discriminatory denial of a Section 401 Water
Quality Certification for the coal terminal violates both the Dormant Commerce
Clause and the Foreign Commerce Clause of the United States Constitution. The
Commerce Clause to the US Constitution authorizes the federal government, not
states, to regulate interstate commerce.
Governor Gordon said that he remains hopeful that the U.S. Supreme Court will
act expeditiously and grant a hearing on this issue that is critical to the
state's economic interests.
The challenge stems from a 2017 decision by the Washington Department of Ecology
to deny permit applications to build a proposed coal terminal in Longview,
Washington called Millennium Bulk. Washington officials denied a Section 401
Water Quality Certification for the Terminal with prejudice, effectively killing
the project.
Dairyland Power Cooperative to retire
Genoa Station #3 in 2021
Dairyland Power Cooperative
announced that its Sustainable Generation Plan includes the retirement of the
coal-fired Genoa Station #3 in mid to late 2021. This decision also aligns with
our Sustainable Generation Plan and its focus on the continued addition of
renewable resources,” said Barb Nick, President. “The recently announced
approval by the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin for the
Nemadji Trail Energy Center in Superior gives us the added confidence
to take this next step to further diversify Dairyland’s resource mix and reduce
our carbon intensity.
It is desirable to determine the impact on flow and treat markets
It is a once through water system. Most of the flyash is sold but about
10’% has been landfilled.
As can be seen below there will be elimination of lime, urea, and activated
carbon as well as replacement bags.
plant name: Genoa
epa unit id: 1
Dairyland Power Cooperative
utility name: Dairyland Power
Cooperative
state: WI
county: Vernon
size MW: 345.6
plant startup: 1969
part addition: ESP, baghouse sized for ACI
part addition startup: 1992, 2010
part addition supplier: ABB
fgd startup: 2010
fgd supplier: Alstom
fgd architect: Sargent & Lundy
fgd reagent: lime
fgd process: dry
nox pc technology: SNCR
Mercury technology: ACI
Two Large
Coal-fired Power Plant retirements in 2020 in Kentucky
The Tennessee Valley Authority’s
Paradise Unit 3 near Drakesboro is scheduled to shutter this December while
Owensboro’s Elmer Smith Generating Station will cease operations in June.
At Paradise there will be lost revenues for
limestone, anhydrous ammonia, catalyst modules, and FGD nozzles.
plant name: Paradise
epa unit id: 3
new owner:
parent utility: Tennessee Valley Authority
utility name: Tennessee Valley Authority
state: KY
county: Muhlenberg
size MW: 1150
future plans:
plant startup: 1970
fuel specific: blend PRB/bit
part original equipment: Cold Side ESP
part manufacturer: American Standard
fgd startup: 2006
fgd supplier: Advatech
fgd changes to original: upgrade 2012
fgd reagent: limestone
fgd process: wet
fgd survivor company: Mitsubishi
fgd process efficiency: 98%
fgd scrubber vessel material: alloy 2205 with
superduplex alloy
nox pc technology: SCR
nox pc supplier: Alstom
nox pc startup: 2003
nox pc catalyst supplier: Cormetech
nox pc efficiency: 90%
nox pc ammonia type: anhydrous
nox pc ammonia supplier: LaRoche
At Elmer Smith the primary difference in the two units shutting down other than
size is that one has SCR and one has SNCR. The lost revenue will be limestone,
urea, and ammonia along with components such as FGD nozzles
plant name: Elmer Smith
epa unit id: 1
new owner:
parent utility: Owensboro Municipal Utilities
utility name: Owensboro Municipal Utilities
state: KY
county: Daviess
size MW: 151
future plans:
plant startup: 1964
fuel specific: Med Sulfur Bit
alternate fuel: None
boiler type: cyclone furnace
boiler manufacturer: Babcock & Wilcox
plant architect: Smith & Loveless
cooling type: once through, fresh water
part addition: ESP
part addition startup: 1993
part addition supplier: Wheelabrator
Fgd startup: 1995
fgd supplier: Wheelabrator
fgd architect: Smith & Loveless
fgd changes to original:
fgd reagent: limestone
fgd process: wet
fgd survivor company: Wheelabrator
fgd process efficiency: 90%
nox pc technology: SCR
nox pc architect: Sargent & Lundy
nox pc startup: 2003
nox pc catalyst supplier: Haldor Topsoe
nox pc ammonia type: anhydrous
nox pc injection system supplier: Wahlco
nox pc dampers supplier: Bachmann
nox pc expansion joints suppliers: Papco
plant name: Elmer Smith
epa unit id: 2
parent utility: Owensboro Municipal Utilities
utility name: Owensboro Municipal Utilities
state: KY
county: Daviess
size MW: 265
plant startup: 1974
fuel specific: Med Sulfur Bit
alternate fuel: None
boiler type: Pulverized Dry Tang Firing
boiler manufacturer: ABB Combustion Engineering
plant architect: Smith & Loveless
cooling type: once through, fresh water
part addition: ESP
part addition startup: 1994
part addition supplier: Wheelabrator
fgd startup: 1995
fgd supplier: Wheelabrator
fgd architect: Smith & Loveless
fgd reagent: limestone
fgd process: wet
fgd survivor company: Wheelabrator
fgd process efficiency: 90%
nox pc technology: SNCR
nox pc supplier: Hamon Research Cottrell
nox pc startup: 2003
COAL – WORLD
Global activists urge Bangladesh
PM to scrap Plans for Coal-fired Power Plants
Forty international civil society organizations, think tanks, and climate
movement platforms have urged prime minister Sheikh Hasina to withdraw the
approval of all coal-fired and other fossil fuel-based power plant projects.
In a petition sent to the prime minister, the organizations requested Hasina to
take steps to generate all power in the country from renewable energy by 2050,
according a press release.
Friends of the Earth,
350.org, Bank Information Centre, Oxfam
Bangladesh among the signatories of the petition, said the release was
issued by NGO Forum on ADB—a Philippines-based international
network of civil society organizations.
The 29 coal-fired power plants, if built, would emit 5.3 billion tons of
carbon-dioxide in their lifetime of 40 years, and would make the climate impact
worse for Bangladesh, according to the petition.
The petitioners raised high concern on the duty exemption of coal power plants.
Bangladesh compensated at least $ 4.45 billion in past 6 years and $ 1 billion
in fiscal year 2018–19 as capacity charge for stranded assets of the independent
power producers as much of generated power by them remained unused, they said.
They said that SS Power Limited, a coal-fired plant owned by the S Alam
Group, had alone got a duty exemption of Tk 3100.71 crore.
In the Paris Agreement of 2016, Bangladesh pledged to reduce greenhouse gas
emissions and to increase renewable energy use at 10 percent by 2021, but so far
met only 4 percent of that target as of November 2019, said the petitioners.
The petitioners also lauded Bangladesh for being the first country to adopt a
resolution in parliament declaring climate change a ‘planetary emergency.’ But,
they said, the decision to increase coal-based power plants is contradictory to
Hasina’s remark on the climate action and also against the nations’ climate
commitments.
Indian Power Utility lobbies to weaken
Pollution Standard
NTPC,
a publicly owned utility, which generates about one-quarter of India’s
electricity, is lobbying for a significant weakening of nitrogen oxide pollution
standards for coal-fired power plants built after 2017. Standards to protect
public health
were announced in 2015, with coal plants commissioned after 2017 not allowed to
exceed nitrogen oxides concentrations of 100 milligrams per cubic meter of air
(mg/Nm3). NTPC wants new plant pollution limits for nitrogen oxides
to be set at 450 mg/Nm3. The Modi Government is already seeking to
lift the nitrogen oxides limit on coal-fired power plants built between 2004 and
2016 from 300 mg/Nm3 to 450 mg/Nm3. NTPC is claiming
trials of nitrogen oxides pollution control in India have proved ineffective at
controlling emissions, a claim disputed by companies involved in the projects.
The revelation comes as coal-fired power plants, in breach of the December 2019
deadline for the installation of flue gas desulfurization
units, continue to operate
without penalty.
German Government negotiates Coal
exit but waters down Commission Recommendations
The German Government has agreed
to allocate €40 billion (US$44 billion) to support economic restructuring of the
four states affected by the closure of hard coal-fired power plants by
2035 and lignite
power plants by 2038. The deal provides for 2,800 megawatts (MW) of lignite
plants to be closed by 2022, 200 MW less than recommended by the coal exit
commission, but with no plants to be closed between 2022 and 2025.
The agreement also allows the
commissioning of the 1,000 MW Datteln 4 unit. The government is also proposing
to allocate €2.6 billion (US$2.9 billion) to RWE for lost revenues
on its plants and a further €1.75 billion (US$1.9 billion) for power utilities
in the east of the country. The deal provides for the demolition of six more
villages to cater for mine expansions but spares Hambach forest, but only as an
island surrounded by mining.
The weakening of the coal exit
commission’s proposed package has been criticized by former commissioners who
argue the government’s proposed legislation should be modified to reflect the
original recommendations. ClientEarth estimates up to 6,000 MW of
lignite plants could still be operating up to 2038.
The Cabinet of Ministers has
approved two new 300 MW coal-fired power plants in Norochcholai and two 300 MW
liquefied natural gas (LNG) plants in Kerawalapitiya amid serious concerns over
an impending power crisis.
Accordingly, Cabinet Co-Spokesperson and Information & Communications
Technology, Higher Education, Technology & Innovations Minister Bandula
Gunawardane revealed that two new 300 MW coal-fired power plants will be built
as an extension to the existing Norochcholai coal-fired power plant.
The former Power and Energy Minister Ravi Karunanayake initially brought the
proposal last year to add a 300 MW coal power plant to the Norochcholai facility
with a loan from China. .
The Cabinet also approved the installation of an LNG (bi-sectorial natural gas
plant) with a capacity of 300MW as a joint venture with Ceylon Electricity Board
(CEB) and India /Japan in Kerawalapitiya.
The lignite-fired power station “Kosovo B” near Pristina will be modernized, in
cooperation with the Government of Kosovo and under the direction of
Engineering Dobersek GmbH, supported by its consortium partners
Hamon Thermal Europe S.A., France and RJM Corporation (EC) Ltd.,
England, trading as RJM International.
This consortium has joined together to deliver the required technical and
commercial solutions as set out in the EU tender. The purpose of the contract is
to significantly reduce nitrogen oxide emissions (NOx from around
700-800 mg/Nm3 to less than 200 mg/Nm3 at 6% O2,
with SNCR), and dust emissions (from 300-700 mg/Nm3 to 20 mg/Nm3),
while improving plant efficiency to recover full load of 339 MWe per boiler, up
from around 292 MWe.
References in South East Europe—including projects financed by the World
Bank and the EU enable Engineering Dobersek to contribute with its
experience to this project in Kosovo.
The consortium leader, Engineering Dobersek (www.dobersek.com
) will coordinate the project and will be responsible for full management of the
site, the pneumatic ash handling system including necessary air supply.
Consortium partner Hamon Thermal will design and supply the Electrostatic
Precipitator filtration system (ESP). The ESP of Hamon are considered as
effective dust collectors with the collection efficiencies of up to 99% with
guaranteed outlet emissions as low as 20 mg/Nm3 with minimal pressure
loss.
Consortium partner RJM International is responsible for designing and
engineering the NOx reduction system, using its combustion modelling
capabilities to achieve the 75% reduction in NOx emissions mandated
by the EU. RJM’s equipment, such as new burner components, will be supplied to
the site by RJM International and installed by Engineering Dobersek.
The reconstruction of the power station will be carried out in two phases. The
works commenced on December 2, 2019. The commissioning of Unit B1 is planned for
the end of 2020 and Unit B2 by the end of 2021. The modernization works are an
important contribution to improving air quality, enhancing environmental
protection and the strengthening of the infrastructure of Kosovo.
With this contract, Engineering Dobersek once more confirms its competence in
the field of power station technologies in South East Europe.
BIOMASS
ANDRITZ to supply a further High-efficiency
PowerFluid Circulating Fluidized Bed Boiler with Biomass Firing in Japan
International technology
group ANDRITZ has received an order from a Joint Venture between
Toyo Engineering Corporation and Nippon Steel Engineering
Co., Ltd., Japan, to deliver a PowerFluid circulating fluidized bed
boiler with a flue gas cleaning system.
The boiler will be part of
a new biomass power plant to be built in Omaezaki in Shizuoka Prefecture, Honshu
Island, some 200 km southwest of Tokyo, Japan, for the Omaezakikou Biomass Power
Plant. Commercial operations are scheduled to begin in mid-2023.
The PowerFluid boiler to
be supplied by ANDRITZ features low emissions, high efficiency and availability,
as well as high fuel flexibility. It forms an essential part of a
high-efficiency biomass power plant for supply of green energy to the national
grid. The biomass power plant fired with wood pellets and palm kernel shells as
main fuels will generate around 75 MWel of power.
This is now the seventh
order in two and a half years for supply of an ANDRITZ PowerFluid circulating
fluidized bed boiler to the Japanese market. This confirms ANDRITZ’s
comprehensive expertise and acknowledged competence in the biomass-fired
fluidized bed boiler sector.
GAS TURBINES
MHPS Technology Upgrades at
Termocandelaria Improve Colombia’s Electric Sector Capacity, Reliability and
Efficiency
Mitsubishi Hitachi Power Systems
(MHPS) and Termocandelaria announced an order for a new MHPS steam
turbine and M501F4 gas turbine upgrades for the Cartagena power plant, along
with an exclusive 15-year Long Term Service Agreement (LTSA). The order will
enable the plant to operate on a combined cycle basis, increasing plant output
by more than 74 percent and improving fuel efficiency by more than 35% — from
10,219 to 6,618 BTU/kWh lower heating value (LHV). It meets Termocandelaria’s
goals to create electricity more affordably and reliably and with lower carbon
emissions.
As part of the service package and MHPS’s long-standing commitment to Latin
America, the company will upgrade the plant’s existing Westinghouse
gas turbines by applying Advanced Class Gas Turbine materials and coatings to
enhance performance, extend maintenance intervals, increase reliability and
lower life cycle maintenance costs.
The LTSA includes the MHPS-TOMONI™ suite of Total Plant Solutions, which uses
artificial intelligence monitoring tools to help guarantee the reliability and
availability of what will be the most efficient combined cycle plant in
Colombia. Marco Sanchez, MHPS Americas Vice President and Head of Intelligent
Solutions, said, “MHPS Total Plant Monitoring develops predictive modeling
scenarios to detect potential maintenance needs before they become issues and to
enable condition-based maintenance.”
The customized MHPS hardware and software solutions will increase plant capacity
from 324 to 566 MW, lower fuel and maintenance costs, and increase plant
flexibility to produce affordable power for the citizens of Cartagena.
Marcos Meireles, Rio Energy’s CEO, said “We are very excited to install the
first GE’s Cypress wind turbines in Brazil. This agreement
reinforces our commitment to help grow Brazil’s installed base, by investing not
only in adding new turbines, but also introducing a new technology to advance
onshore wind in Brazil.”
The contract also includes a ten-year operation and maintenance (O&M) agreement
for all equipment supplied by GE at the wind farm, with the potential to extend
to 20 years.
WASTE-TO-ENERGY
Commercial operations achieved at
Two New Wheelabrator Technologies Waste-to-Energy Facilities in U.K.
Wheelabrator Technologies
realized major milestones in the U.K. in 2019 when two new waste-to-energy
facilities reached full commercial operations.
After three years of construction, the creation of approximately 1,500 jobs and
$110K (£85K) in contributions to local community causes and initiatives, the
waste-to-energy facilities—Wheelabrator Parc Adfer, located at Deeside in North
Wales, and Ferrybridge Multifuel 2 (FM2) in West Yorkshire—commenced operations
in late December and will now play a critical role in the region's environmental
and energy infrastructure.
Combined, Wheelabrator Parc Adfer and FM2 will process up to 964,000 tons per
year (875,000 tonnes) of residual waste. Together, they will utilize waste as a
fuel to generate a total output of 98MW (gross)/89 MW (net), enough electricity
to power an estimated 210,000 U.K. homes and businesses.
The facilities will divert residual waste from landfill, prevent the need for
export of waste to continental Europe, reduce greenhouse gases, recycle metals
that would otherwise go to landfill and generate clean, renewable baseload
energy.
Wheelabrator entered the U.K. market in 2009 to target Private Finance
Initiatives (PFIs) and shortly after commenced its support for the startup of
Riverside Resource Recovery Facility in Belvedere, London, leveraging
Wheelabrator's operational excellence in the U.S. over the last 45 years.
Wheelabrator has since successfully developed, financed and managed the
construction of four waste-to-energy facilities. The first to be delivered was
Ferrybridge Mutlitfuel 1 (FM1), part of the Multifuel Energy Limited (MEL) joint
venture with SSE, which commenced commercial operations in July 2015 to process
744,000 tons per year (675,000 tonnes) and generate 79MW (gross)/72MW (net)
after being built by Hitachi Zozen Inova (HZI). It is now recognized as one of
the most efficient waste-to-energy facilities in the U.K. FM2, also built by
HZI, is expected to achieve comparable levels of performance, being managed by
the same management team within the MEL joint venture. Since commencing full
operations in December, Wheelabrator Parc Adfer, built by EPC contractor CNIM,
has performed exceptionally well with a capacity of 220,000 tons per year
(200,000 tonnes). Wheelabrator Kemsley, also being built by CNIM, is currently
progressing hot commissioning and is expected to come online in Q2 2020. The
facility will process 605,000 tons (550,000 tonnes) and generate 69MW
(gross)/63MW (net) when the facility is taken over from CNIM.
Once all four assets are operational, they will process 2.3M tons (2.1M tonnes)
of residual household and commercial waste, and generate 1.1M net MWh of
renewable, baseload energy each year.
Bob Boucher, President and CEO at Wheelabrator, said: "This is a significant
accomplishment for our business and is transformational for our team in the U.K.
as we commence operations at both Wheelabrator Parc Adfer, and FM2, the second
facility within our MEL joint venture with SSE. Growth in this market has been
our number one strategic priority and I am proud of our team and our customers
for continuing to demand and support sustainable waste management in the U.K.
Takeover of these two facilities is the result of many years of commitment, hard
work and strong partnerships with our customers and the communities we operate
within."
"There remains a significant capacity gap in this market, and we continue to
explore opportunities to develop new waste-to-energy facilities to ensure local,
sustainable waste management solutions, and provide energy security for the U.K.
With limited landfill space, high landfill taxes, high costs and increasing
barriers to exporting waste to continental Europe and the need to invest in
baseload electricity generation, Wheelabrator is well-positioned to unlock
future opportunities to provide sustainable waste management to local
communities."
Wheelabrator's active development pipeline is already well-advanced with a
further three U.K. projects, Wheelabrator Kemsley North in Kent, located next to
our almost complete Wheelabrator Kemsley facility, Wheelabrator Harewood in
Hampshire, and Skelton Grange in Yorkshire, which will be developed with SSE as
part of the MEL joint venture.
Boucher said: "We look forward to continuing to develop, deliver and realize the
potential of clean energy in the U.K."
NUCLEAR
GE Hitachi Nuclear Energy and TerraPower
announce Collaboration to Support Versatile Test Reactor Program
GE Hitachi Nuclear Energy
(GEH) and TerraPower have announced a collaboration to pursue a
Public Private Partnership to design and construct the Versatile Test Reactor
(VTR) for the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE).
The two companies recently submitted a joint response to an Expression of
Interest issued by the Battelle Energy Alliance (BEA) on behalf of
the DOE, which seeks stakeholders interested in forming a partnership for a cost
sharing arrangement to design and construct the VTR utilizing sodium fast
reactor technology.
"This collaboration brings together a strong team of engineers and scientists,
which has considerable experience in sodium reactor technology," said Jay
Wileman, President & CEO of GEH. "The combined team has complementary and unique
experience with the credibility to lead the VTR design, procurement and
construction effort. We are excited to work with TerraPower on such an important
project."
"To achieve nuclear energy’s full potential, business and government must work
together to invest in both testing new materials and demonstrating advanced
technologies,” said Chris Levesque, TerraPower CEO. “America’s nuclear workforce
is ready to build next generation nuclear technology to deliver affordable,
clean energy, and to reestablish American leadership in nuclear technology. The
VTR offers a domestic platform for innovation that promotes American economic
and national security.”
Energy Northwest,
a utility consortium with nuclear power plant operating experience, will support
the joint GEH-TerraPower effort. Additional companies and investors have
expressed interest in being part of this effort and, if brought on board, will
be named later.
The U.S. Department of Energy Office of Nuclear Energy established
the VTR program to introduce fast neutron spectrum technology that does not
currently exist in the U.S. and to support accelerated development of nuclear
fuels and materials for advanced reactors.
In November 2018, BEA selected GEH and its PRISM technology to support the VTR
program. Since then GEH has been actively engaged in development of the VTR
conceptual design. TerraPower has supported the VTR program by making
enhancements to the VTR’s design and has invested ten years of sodium technology
development into its traveling wave reactor.
SNC-Lavalin contracts to extend Life of
CANDU Reactor at Romanian Nuclear Plant
Candu
Energy
will work on upgrades to extend the operating life of a 24-year-old Romanian
nuclear power unit.
Candu, a member of the
SNC-Lavalin
Group,
was awarded a $10.8 million contract by
Societatea
Nationala Nuclearelectrica S.A.
(SNN) for engineering analysis and assessments on the Cernavoda Unit 1 CANDU
nuclear reactor. The contract is focused on the fuel channel and feeders
assemblies with the objective of extending the operating life of the plant by
approximately 4 years, up to 245,000 effective full power hours (EFPH) from the
original design life of 210,000 EFPH. The extensions would enable the Cernavoda
plant to operate safely until it is ready for refurbishment in 2026.
In October, SNN had also awarded SNC-Lavalin and its partner
Ansaldo
Nucleare
the condition assessment work which will determine the scope of repair and
replacement of other equipment as part of the Cernavoda Unit 1 refurbishment
outage.
“SNC-Lavalin looks forward to continuing our long relationship with SNN to
optimize the operation of Cernavoda Unit 1 in preparation for a refurbishment
that will contribute to over 60 years of CANDU reactor life,” said Sandy Taylor,
President, Nuclear, SNC-Lavalin. “Our dedicated project execution team has
exceptional expertise in this area, having completed similar assessments for
several CANDU clients around the world.”
Cernavoda Unit 1 produces over 700 MW of electricity, about 10 percent of
Romania’s electricity demands. It was commissioned and began commercial full
power operation in December 1996.
Nuclear power units do not emit carbon dioxide. Officials estimate that
Cernavoda Unit 1 has avoided the release of more than four million metric tonnes
of CO2 annually that would have been produced by a coal-fired plant,
according to the release.
CANDU, known as Canada Deuterium Uranium, was invented in Canada. It uses
deuterium oxide as a moderator and uranium as a fuel, according to the Canadian
Nuclear Association.
The CANDU reactor also has been used at the Bruce, Darlington and Pickering
power plants.
ACCESSING ALL THE PROJECTS AND INFORMATION ONLINE
This Utility E-Alert is part of the Utility Tracking System. The system allows
you to instantly retrieve project details, profiles of each coal-fired power
plant worldwide, the right contacts at the OEM and A/E firms and summaries of
all the scheduled FGD and SCR projects. You need a user name and password to
access this system. If you have forgotten your user name or password or are not
sure whether you are eligible to access this system, please send email to
editor@mcilvainecompany.com.
*** The Utility E-Alert is for the exclusive use of the registered subscriber to
whom it is electronically delivered. Unauthorized distribution is prohibited.
***
© 2020 McIlvaine Company