PRECIP 
NEWSLETTER 

                                                                                                January 2007

                                                                                                      No. 372

SO3 Impacts Plant Performance

Emissions of SO3 (or its hydrated form, H2SO4) have received increasing attention. Though much of this attention has focused on plume opacity, SO3 also has significant negative impacts on plant performance and operations. Robert E. Moser, Codan Development LLC, writing in Power, related that these impacts include:

· Reduction of unit heat rate and increased corrosion of downstream equipment;

· Fouling of air heaters and SCR catalysts from the reaction of SO3 with ammonia;

· Competition of SO3 with mercury for adsorption sites on activated carbon, reducing the effectiveness of mercury control.

Burning any type of coal will produce some SO3 in the boiler. It can vary from a few ppm to 40 ppm or more. The application of SCR for NOx removal can also result in an increase in SO3 produced. SO3 exists in a vapor form in the high-temperature environment of the boiler. As the flue gas cools below 600° F to 700° F, and depending on the amount of moisture present, vaporous sulfuric acid is formed. By the time the average gas temperature falls to 280° F to 320° F downstream of the air heater, most of the SO3 has assumed the form of vaporous sulfuric acid. As the flue gas is rapidly cooled in the FGD system, the vaporous sulfuric acid undergoes a shock condensation process that produces very fine aerosol particles. Note that the term “SO3” invariably refers to varying proportions of vaporous SO3 and vaporous sulfuric acid, and to sulfuric acid aerosol particles downstream of the wet FGD system.

The presence of SO3 in flue gas creates a number of plant O&M issues that go far beyond “blue plumes,” although, the plumes are also problematic. The optical light-scattering effects of sulfuric acid aerosols produce a visual discoloration of the plume. The minimum concentration of SO3 necessary for this phenomenon depends on atmospheric conditions (the amount of sunshine, temperature, relative humidity, wind speed) and stack specifics (stack diameter and exit gas velocity). However, it is generally accepted that if the SO3 concentration is less than 5 ppm, there will be no visual discoloration effects.

The sulfuric acid dew point temperature is the temperature at which acid will condense on a surface. It is largely a function of flue gas SO3 concentration, with dew point temperature increasing as SO3 goes up. Normally, the average air heater flue gas outlet temperature is maintained about 20° to 30° F above the average dewpoint. However, as a unit accumulates operating hours, air inleakage increases and this lowers the temperature. This makes all of the components in the back end gas stream the cold-end baskets of the air heater, ductwork, expansion joints, the ESP and induced-draft fans more vulnerable to acid corrosion.

When an SCR system is placed in service, the acid dew point can increase anywhere from 10° F to 20° F due to the increased SO3 concentrations leaving the unit. If the air heater outlet temperature is not raised, the risk of acid corrosion increases. However, raising the outlet temperature reduces the unit heat rate. For example, raising air heater outlet temperature by 35° F would raise unit heat rate by 1 percent.

SO3 and ammonia (NH3) will react to form ammonium bisulfate (ABS) in the air heater if both substances are present when the gas in the heater cools to between 350° F and 420° F. The SO3 must be present in molar concentration in excess of the molar concentration of NH3. ABS is a sticky solid that can foul the air heater and increase the pressure drop. The driving force for this reaction becomes the amount of NH3 slip from the SCR.

Depending on its concentration, SO3 can also react with NH3 under the catalytic conditions that exist in the SCR system at temperatures in the range of 530° F to 630° F. This is typically referred to as the SCR system’s minimum operating temperature (MOT). Operating at temperatures below the MOT can cause pluggage of the SCR catalyst.

The use of fabric filters at plants burning high-sulfur coals is usually avoided because SO3 can foster corrosion of a filter’s metal components and adversely affect filter cake properties. However, with respect to mercury control with activated carbon injection, fabric filters are now being installed on a number of units and it is possible that significantly more will be installed in the near future. The greatest concern is the fact that as SO3 collects on the filter cake, it becomes noticeably heavier and stickier, making the cake more difficult to remove, and increases pressure drop.

There is at least one positive impact that SO3 has on plant operation. When SO3 is absorbed onto flyash, the resistivity of the ash decreases, enhancing the ability of the ESP to remove it. Nevertheless, acid condensation on the ash causes corrosion of ESP components, raising the maintenance costs of ESP units.

  Back to PRECIP Newsletter No. 372 Table of Contents