Connecting Things, People, Intelligence, Niche Experts and Wise Crowds for Power 
Industry Decisions
GE, Emerson, Siemens and many other companies are creating software to connect 
things.  There is a large potential 
for this in power generation.  This 
potential was reflected in a number of papers and displays at the recent 
PowerGen Asia exhibition.
“We believe the success of our power generation customers will be more and more 
supported by the intelligent use of data generated by ever increasing 
connectivity of devices. The integration of those data with people expertise and 
knowledge will create additional services in a cycle delivering unprecedented 
knowledge of the behavior and potential of their assets,” said Marco Sanguineti, 
Head of Technology for ABB’s Power Generation business unit. 
McIlvaine recently conducted nine hours of webinars focused on a problem for one 
utility.  Presentations by Siemens, 
GE and Emerson addressed the optimization route to a lowest total cost of 
ownership (TCO) solution but the participants (wise crowd) concluded that 
incorporating innovative new technologies and components would be equally 
important in a system which would provide the lowest TCO.
Companies such as ABB are integrating the data from many thousands of sensors 
which are monitoring thousands of pumps, valves, mixers, fans, compressors, 
burners, conveyors, filters, etc.  
In a large utility with multiple plants, there are hundreds of individuals with 
specialized knowledge that may be valuable in a specific lowest TCO 
determination. As a result, there are likely to be many thousands of people who 
can contribute to the decision-making process. How do you take advantage of all 
this niche expertise?
Jeff Immelt of GE observed that the power industry needs to adopt the “hurry up” 
attitude of Silicon Valley in developing new technology. 
McIlvaine believes that this “hurry up” mode can best be achieved by 
decision systems which interconnect machines with people, intelligent databases 
and systems, niche experts and wise crowds. 
Systems have been created which provide the four knowledge needs: 
Alerts, Answers, Analysis and Advancement. The newest addition has been 
to supplement periodic webinars with very focused LinkedIn discussion groups. 
These groups facilitate “wise crowd” decisions by addressing all the 
criteria needed for a “wise crowd” to function properly. 
Wise Crowd Criteria and LinkedIn Role
| 
																
																
																Criteria | 
																
																
																Description | 
																
																
																LinkedIn role | 
																
																 | 
| 
												
												Diversity of Opinion | 
												
												Each person should have private 
												information.  | 
												
												Small LinkedIn discussion groups 
												lend themselves to extracting 
												the niche expertise and unique 
												ideas. | 
												 | 
| 
												
												Independence | 
												
												People's opinions aren't 
												determined by the opinions of 
												those around them. | 
												
												The small LinkedIn discussion 
												groups are not subject to the 
												peer pressure of the large 
												webinars. 
												McIlvaine editors then 
												integrate the conclusions 
												reached in the discussion 
												groups. | 
												 | 
| 
												
												Decentralization | 
												
												People can specialize and draw 
												on local knowledge. | 
												
												The small LinkedIn discussion 
												group is the ideal way to 
												extract the local knowledge and 
												benefit from niche expert 
												participation.  | 
												 | 
| 
												
												Aggregation | 
												
												Some mechanism exists for 
												turning private judgments into a 
												collective decision. | 
												
												The LinkedIn discussion groups 
												are a bridge between analyses 
												and webinars which result in the 
												collective decisions. | 
												 | 
The LinkedIn discussion groups are an important part of the entire 
interconnection system between:
·      
Separate individuals and divisions within a supplier conglomerate
·      
Separate individuals and divisions within a utility conglomerate
·      
Separate individuals and divisions within a consulting company
·      
The final interconnection between all the many individuals in each of the above
Supplier knowledge can be transmitted through individuals who are encouraged by 
management to focus on becoming more expert. 
These individuals will be “rainmakers.” 
If they demonstrate that their company has the knowledge and the products 
to provide the lowest TCO, they can be very effective in boosting sales.
The same is true of consulting companies. However, the challenge will be to 
offer just enough expertise to achieve the rainmaking without reducing the 
potential actual consulting revenues.
The LinkedIn discussion groups are incorporated in three Decision Guides:
4S01 Berkshire Hathaway Energy Supplier and Utility Connect
44I  
Coal fired Power Plant Decisions (formerly 
PPAQD)
59D Gas 
Turbine and Reciprocating Engine Decisions
Water Treatment Chemicals Market is Growing Faster than GDP
The expansion of municipal drinking and wastewater treatment in Asia is one of 
the driving forces which will ensure that growth in the water treatment 
chemicals market will exceed the rise in GDP. 
The 2017 market is forecast at $27 billion. 
This is the latest forecast in 
N026 Water and Wastewater Treatment Chemicals: World Market. 
Corrosion inhibitors will be the leading product segment.
| 
																
																
																Subject | 
																
																
																2017 | 
| 
												
												
												 Total | 
												
												 27,585
   | 
| 
												
												 Activated Carbon | 
												
												 772 | 
| 
												
												 Chelants | 
												
												 663
   | 
| 
												
												 Corrosion Inhibitors | 
												
												 6,111
   | 
| 
												
												 Defoamers | 
												
												 608
   | 
| 
												
												 Inorganic Flocculants | 
												
												 3,459
   | 
| 
												
												 Ion Exchange | 
												
												 903
   | 
| 
												
												 Odor Control | 
												
												 956
   | 
| 
												
												 Organic Flocculants | 
												
												 4,497
   | 
| 
												
												 Other | 
												
												 1,389
   | 
| 
												
												 Oxidizers & Biocides | 
												
												 2,993
   | 
| 
												
												 pH Adjusters | 
												
												 1,486
   | 
| 
												
												 Scale Inhibitors | 
												
												 3,748
   | 
Water treatment chemicals are part of a larger category labeled specialty 
chemicals or performance chemicals.  
The market for this broader category is $1 trillion per year. Large players 
include Dow Chemical, BASF, Bayer, INEOS Group and DuPont. 
The major markets for specialty chemicals are: 
·       
Agrochemicals
·       
Polymers & Plastic Additives
·       
Construction Chemicals
·       
Electronic Chemicals
·       
Cleaning Chemicals
·       
Surfactants
·       
Lubricants & Oilfield Chemicals
·       
Specialty Coatings
·       
Paper & Textile Chemicals
·       
Food Additives
·       
Adhesives & Sealants
The major revenue producers in the water treatment chemicals market are 
formulators such as Ecolab (Nalco) and GE Water (Betz). 
They in turn are buying the specialty chemicals which they then mix and 
sell along with service expertise.
A number of acquisitions have taken place in the industry in recent years. In 
the most recent announcement, Lanxess AG agreed to buy U.S. competitor Chemtura 
Corp. for about $2.1 billion in cash, more than doubling the size of its 
additives business and accelerating a shift towards specialty chemicals. 
Chemtura sales are €1.5 billion with a pretax EBITA of €245 million. 
Chemtura sells bromine directly to some large customers but is also a 
supplier to formulators such as Ecolab. GE is planning to divest its water 
business.  This includes the Betz water treatment chemicals.  The sale 
of this group will have an impact on the market going forward.  The 
divestiture target date is mid-2017. 
The forecasts do not include the pH adjusters used in scrubbers. There is a very 
large market for lime and sodium compounds sold to power plants and other 
industrial emitters.  Lime and 
limestone react with SO2 to form gypsum. Much of the world’s gypsum 
wallboard is made with flue gas desulfurization (FGD) gypsum.
For more information on 
N026 Water and Wastewater Treatment Chemicals: World Market, 
click on: 
http://home.mcilvainecompany.com/index.php/markets/27-water/449-n026-water-and-wastewater-treatment-chemicals.
Who Should Purchase GE Water?
Hundreds of companies in the water business as well as private investors will be 
considering the purchase of GE Water. The first conclusion in a cursory review 
will be that this is a group of individual companies which operate independently 
and are not necessarily in the same markets. 
There are companies selling systems and major components, small 
components, instruments and consumables such as treatment chemicals. 
The management of these businesses is challenging because of their diversity. 
The way you manage an effort to supply $50 cartridges is totally 
different than the way you manage an effort to sell knowledge which is bundled 
into the price of formulated chemicals. The management of a company which sells 
complete zero liquid discharge (ZLD) systems requires skills not required in 
some of the other businesses.
Danaher has been mentioned in the media as a potential purchaser. 
Their recent Pall acquisition has made Danaher a major player in 
pharmaceutical and chemical industry filtration. 
GE Water is focused more on power, oil and gas, refining and to a lesser 
degree on various water-related purification. 
So, the industry alignment is complimentary.
Xylem has grown the test segment of its transport, treat and test efforts. Its 
instrumentation or test business is mostly in municipal water and wastewater and 
compliments the GE instrumentation applications. 
Other water chemical formulators such as Ecolab and Solenis and basic water 
chemical suppliers such BASF and Kemira are also potential purchasers.
Any of the large companies in the air, water, liquid, gas flow and treat 
businesses with an industry total revenue of $323 billion are potential 
purchasers.
| 
								
								
								Air/Water/Gas, Liquid Flow and Treat Revenues 
								 
								
								
								$ Millions | ||||||
| 
								
								
								Product | 
								
								
								Power | 
								
								
								Fluid | 
								
								
								Municipal | 
								
								
								Industrial and Other | 
								
								
								Residential/ | 
								
								
								Total | 
| 
								
								
								Flow (Water) | ||||||
| 
								
								Pumps | 
								
								3 | 
								
								8 | 
								
								14 | 
								
								20 | 
								
								8 | 
								
								53 | 
| 
								
								Valves | 
								
								7 | 
								
								13 | 
								
								7 | 
								
								39 | 
								
								20 | 
								
								86 | 
| 
								
								Subtotal | 
								
								10 | 
								
								21 | 
								
								21 | 
								
								59 | 
								
								28 | 
								
								139 | 
| 
								
								
								Liquid Treatment | ||||||
| 
								
								Cartridge | 
								
								0 | 
								
								7 | 
								
								1 | 
								
								6 | 
								
								7 | 
								
								21 | 
| 
								
								Sedimentation/ Centrifugation | 
								
								1 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								2 | 
								
								5 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								8 | 
| 
								
								Cross Flow Membranes | 
								
								2 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								4 | 
								
								3 | 
								
								1 | 
								
								10 | 
| 
								
								Macrofiltration | 
								
								1 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								2 | 
								
								4 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								7 | 
| 
								
								Subtotal | 
								
								4 | 
								
								7 | 
								
								9 | 
								
								18 | 
								
								8 | 
								
								46 | 
| 
								
								
								Oxidation and Destruction (Water) | ||||||
| 
								
								Biological/Oxidation/Destruction | 
								
								1 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								8 | 
								
								4 | 
								
								2 | 
								
								15 | 
| 
								
								Water/Wastewater Chemicals | 
								
								5 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								9 | 
								
								10 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								24 | 
| 
								
								Subtotal | 
								
								6 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								17 | 
								
								14 | 
								
								2 | 
								
								39 | 
| 
								
								
								Indoor Air Treatment | ||||||
| 
								
								Filtration/Purification | 
								
								1 | 
								
								2 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								3 | 
								
								5* | 
								
								11 | 
| 
								
								
								Stack Gas Treatment and Flow | ||||||
| 
								
								Fabric Filter | 
								
								1 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								5 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								6 | 
| 
								
								Scrubber | 
								
								0 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								1 | 
								
								5 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								6 | 
| 
								
								Precipitator | 
								
								7 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								1 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								8 | 
| 
								
								FGD | 
								
								7 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								7 | 
| 
								
								DeNOx | 
								
								6 | 
								
								2 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								1 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								9 | 
| 
								
								Thermal/Catalytic | 
								
								0 | 
								
								10 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								2 | 
								
								0 | 
								
								12 | 
| 
								
								Fans and Compressors | 
								
								4 | 
								
								2 | 
								
								2 | 
								
								12 | 
								
								5 | 
								
								25 | 
| 
								
								Subtotal | 
								
								25 | 
								
								14 | 
								
								3 | 
								
								26 | 
								
								5 | 
								
								73 | 
| 
								
								
								Monitoring | ||||||
| 
								
								Air | 
								
								1 | 
								
								1 | 
								
								1 | 
								
								1 | 
								
								3 | 
								
								7 | 
| 
								
								Water | 
								
								1 | 
								
								1 | 
								
								3 | 
								
								2 | 
								
								1 | 
								
								8 | 
| 
								
								Subtotal | 
								
								2 | 
								
								2 | 
								
								4 | 
								
								3 | 
								
								4 | 
								
								15 | 
| 
								
								
								Total | 
								
								  | 
								
								  | 
								
								  | 
								
								  | 
								
								  | 
								
								
								323 | 
* includes vacuum bags and face masks as well as HVAC
| 
								
								GE Water Coverage | 
								 | 
The GE water treatment chemicals business is of greater value as the percentage 
reduction of end user knowledge to total knowledge continues to shrink. 
The formulated chemicals business is more problem solving with the right 
combination rather than sale of a product. 
Knowledge of the applications is critical. 
With the development of the smart sensors, the formulators can become 
remote operators or continuous advisors rather than just offering periodic 
advice as part of the chemical sale. Will potential investors fully recognize 
this opportunity?   If they do, 
the potential buyer will be one who can best leverage this very large potential. 
The expertise in the use of chemicals along with filtration, valves, 
pumps, etc. will all create a very large remote advice, operations and 
preventive maintenance revenue opportunity.
The various relevant market reports for an evaluation of this opportunity are 
shown at: 
Markets
Here are some Headlines from the Utility E-Alert – January 13, 2017
UTILITY E-ALERT
#1305 – January 13, 2017
COAL – US
·      
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is proposing to approve a State 
Implementation Plan (SIP) revision submitted by the State of Maryland
·      
Basin Electric will be required to install NOx Controls on Three 
Plants in Wyoming
·      
Court of Appeals reaffirms Clean Air Act Requirements in DTE Case
COAL – WORLD 
·      
NLC India may acquire Ind-Barath Coal-fired Power Plant in Odisha
·      
India will produce One Billion Tons of Coal per Year by 2020
·      
Bataan Coal-fired Power Plant’s operation stopped amid complaints of Ash Fall
·      
Pushing for Coal-fired Power Plant in Mackay, Whitsunday, Isaac Region, 
Australia
·      
ABB supplies Balance-of-Plant Electricals for large Indian Coal-fired Power 
Plants
·      
Anjana Portland Cement commissions Coal-fired Power Plant 
·      
Fortum to supply Low-NOx Combustion Technology for Krakow Coal-fired 
Power Plant
The
41F 
Utility E-Alert
is issued weekly and covers the coal-fired projects, regulations and 
other information important to the suppliers. It is $950/yr. but is included in 
the $3020
42EI Utility 
Tracking System which 
has data on every plant and project plus networking directories and many other 
features.
44I: Coal Fired Power Plant Decisions
$1600.00/year (Additional Users $120.00/year)
This service provides a connection for suppliers and coal-fired power plant 
operators around the world.  It is 
free of charge to any coal-fired utility employee. 
It is designed to help owners make lowest cost of ownership decisions. 
The service covers combustion systems and components, flow control and treatment 
and air, water and solid waste pollution control. 
It addresses the four knowledge needs: 
Alerts, Answers, Analysis, Advancement.
Alerts:  Six alerts and newsletters 
are included.  The latest entries in 
the intelligence system are easily accessed. 
Daily entries in LinkedIn discussion groups are also available.
Answers:  The intelligence system 
includes case histories, product information, regulatory analyses and all the 
past newsletters dating back to 1999 (over 1000 newsletters). 
Hundreds of hours of recorded webinars provide graphic as well as text 
answers.
Analysis:  Upcoming webinars, the 
newsletters, white papers in the intelligence systems and detailed discussions 
in the LinkedIn groups provide analytical data. 
Focus on seeking the lowest total cost of ownership is one of the most 
valuable aspects of the service.
Advancement:  The extensive webinar 
library and intelligence system provide the material for tailored training 
programs.  If fills the needs of the 
trainee but also senior people who just want to keep up with the latest 
developments.
Click Here
for more information
Bob McIlvaine
President
847-784-0012 ext. 112
rmcilvaine@mcilvainecompany.com
www.mcilvainecompany.com